The PGA Tour’s Exclusivity Grows w/ the Closing of Qualifying School’s Doors

Dec 05, 2012 9 Comments
PGA West Stadium Course

Part of the final Q-School was held at PGA West Stadium Course. Photo By: Scott Vonderohe

You may not have realized it, watched it, or even known about it, but this past weekend the PGA Tour’s Qualifying School closed it’s doors effectively ending one of the few ways aspiring golf professionals have at reaching the upper echelons of the sport.

For those unfamiliar “Q-School,” as it is often called, it was the yearly competition where professional golfers compete through multiple stages of tournament play in an effort to obtain a mere 25 tour cards. A grueling test of a golfer’s moxie and resolve, it’s been called golf’s 5th major by author John Feinstein and perhaps rightfully so, as the weight of one’s career and/or financial security relies on being one of the fortunate few to finish in the Top 25 of the final tournament.  It’s a process where hopeful professionals can spend weeks competing in up to four different stages of tournaments, at a cost of upwards of $13,000, and still fall short of their dream because of one errant shot, a gust of wind, an unfortunate bounce, or a putt that lipped out of the hole instead of dropping in.

PGA Tour LogoThe pressure is intense simply because of what is at stake…a chance to join an elite group of less than 250 golfers with tour cards and all the privileges that come with it.

And what made Qualifying School so great was that it represented one of two ways* that professionals from lower level tours could obtain a tour card simply by performing at a high level in each stage of the process. It was a difficult, yet reasonable avenue, through which anyone, even the random joe off the street, could earn their way onto golf’s highest stage.  Just as the immortal Tin Cup once said, “If you win, then you’re in.”

However, after 50+ years of service, the Q-School door is now permanently closed. Closed because of the PGA Tour’s desire to bring legitimacy and stability to it’s developmental tour formerly known as the Nationwide Tour and now known as the Tour.

To do so, the PGA Tour has created an qualification format that is exclusively for professionals presently or formerly in the PGA system of tours and no one else. The field will consist of top money earners from the tour and PGA Tour players who failed finish high enough on the money list to retain their cards.

While this move might lead to more interest in the developmental tour and possibly, as the PGA argues, a high caliber of golfer on the PGA Tour, it also effectively reduces the number of aspiring golfers that will ever have an opportunity to compete for a PGA Tour card.

True Q-School was a shortcut to the top, but it was always a shortcut that had to be earned.  Now golfers on lower level regional tours, are forced not only to qualify for the Tour but also finish in the upper echelons of the money list to have the opportunity to earn PGA Tour card.

Camilo Villegas

Camilo Villegas, one of the many former PGA Tour players who failed to earn his card in this year’s Q-School. Photo By: Keith Allison

Effectively the road to the PGA Tour just got longer and harder for the lower level professionals who are barely scrapping by because of high expenses and low earnings.

I realize that for most people out there, changing the rules and the format for how a small number of people are attempting to collect a piece of a very large pie isn’t necessarily all that important.

However, Q-School was one of the most inclusive aspects of a sport that oozes exclusivity on the professional side. It represented opportunity, chance, and above all reward for golfers who had big dreams and could seize the day.

Sure the percentages of starting at the bottom of Q-School, working your way through four stages of competition, and finishing in the Top 25 were low.  But there was always a chance and opportunity to do so.

Now with the door closed it feels as if a part of the American dream is gone, at least for professional golfers, and it has left a sour taste in my mouth.  Yes, the PGA Tour has the right to conduct their business in any way they see fit to make a profit, but the Tour has just become much less democratic and welcoming of all.

Thank you for the opportunities and RIP Q-School.

*The second avenue is via the Monday qualifier and pre-qualifier where hundreds of golfers compete for the right to play in the PGA tournament of that week with typically only the top 4 players receiving spots. 

Copyright ©, 2010-2012. All Rights Reserved. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from is strictly prohibited.

Golf, Sports Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

9 Responses to “The PGA Tour’s Exclusivity Grows w/ the Closing of Qualifying School’s Doors”

  1. The Mom Chef ~ Taking on Magazines One Recipe at a Time says:

    I’m sitting here trying to wrap my brain around the fact that the PGA did this. It seems like such a step backwards for one of the only sports that’s had so much trouble taking steps forward in the first place. Wow.

    • Jed Gray says:

      Unfortunately, money rules the day for the PGA. Still they might come to regret this decision in the end.

  2. sportsattitudes says:

    I was not aware of this until I read your post. This is really hard to believe. A sport that many feel is reserved for an elite few just got true justification for feeling that way. The recently-deceased qualifying format opened the door for the underdogs of golf…and let anyone feel they had a shot. This is a bad decision indeed.

    • Jed Gray says:

      Hey Bruce…it really is a sad day for all of us who have tried to make a run at the PGA. At least the Monday Qualifiers are still there and thankfully there is always the US Open, which I can’t believe will ever change. Cheers!

  3. Sportschump says:

    Good piece, man.

    I didn’t realize the tour was suffering from a lack of quality golfers. Doesn’t seem like it to me.

    It’s too bad. Golf could always use good stories like that.

    Guess I’ll have to go back to watching Tin Cup.

    • Jed Gray says:

      Thanks Chris and of course you know which movie most pro golfers have the greatest disdain for is…Tin Cup. Though somehow they love seeing a course being blown up in Caddieshack.

  4. ChgoJohn says:

    Is this really that surprising? They fought to prohibit a disabled golfer from using a golf cart. They hold prestigious tournaments at courses where women can play “by invitation only,” if that.
    Elitist? You betcha!

    • Jed Gray says:

      Perhaps not tremendously surprising, but disappointing none the less. I do think if the tour had promoted the uniqueness of Q-school and made money off it, then the avenue would still remain. Overall, it is a somewhat hypocritical move for an organization that supports the First Tee and “diversifying” the sport.

  5. Shana says:

    Just want to say your article is as astonishing.
    The clearness to your post is just cool and that i can assume you are
    an expert on this subject. Fine with your permission allow me to
    grab your feed to stay up to date with approaching post.

    Thanks one million and please carry on the gratifying work.

%d bloggers like this: